10 perfect places to order pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving

Magnific By Kaity Young Today at 5:00 AM Listen Share Share this article Share Facebook X LinkedIn Email Print News Promotion News Promotion An article written by the newsroom that draws attention to other article(s) of interest. The Trust Project What is this? As Thanksgiving approaches, it's time to start thinking about what you'll be serving for dessert. For most, there's one must-have classic: pumpkin pie. On a day when cooking can keep some cooped up in the kitchen, consider saving some time and effort by letting someone else handle the baking. You can trust that the pies from these 10 spots across the Upper Midwest will taste homemade. ADVERTISEMENT Rustic Inn Cafe Less than an hour up the shore from Duluth is the North Shore's favorite dessert spot: Rustic Inn Cafe. This from-scratch kitchen is known for making the best pies around, and the pumpkin pie is no exception. While it's worth the drive to stop in and enjoy lunch before bringing home a pie, pies from Rustic Inn can be ordered on their website and start at $25. Nichole's Fine Pastry Alyssa Goelzer / The Forum In the heart of downtown Fargo, Nichole's Fine Pastry & Cafe is known for creating seasonal desserts and savory dishes all year long. The pumpkin pie is simple and beautiful, with a classic filling and leaf decor on top. If you're serving only a couple of people, you can order a 5-inch pie for just $12, while 8-inch pies come in at $30. You can even order fresh whipped cream for an extra decadent dessert. Orders should be placed no later than Nov. 21. People's Food Co-op More than an organic grocery store, People's Food Co-op in Rochester can pull double duty for you this season. Their pumpkin pie is a classic, with custard filling and a crispy, flaky crust. Their pies are affordable, at $15 each. Orders must be placed no later than 6 p.m. on Nov. 22. Pink Apron Bakery Macy Moore / West Central Tribune It's fitting that Pink Apron Bakery in Spicer would be serving up a Pumpkin Spice Pie this season. This family recipe has the classic pumpkin custard filling in a hand-made flaky crust. ADVERTISEMENT Looking for a twist? Try the Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake Pie, which blends a vanilla cheesecake with the spiced pumpkin pie. Pies start at $32 and must be picked up Nov. 25. Baranko Bakery Dickinson's Baranko Bakery is offering traditional and inventive pumpkin pies this season. The Traditional Pumpkin Pie is exactly what you'd exped, while the Pumpkin White Chocolate Caramel Pie is deeply indulgent. Pre-orders are limited, so order early ahead of the Nov. 24 pickup. Pies start at $25. Michelle's Mad Batter Adam Thury / Mitchell Republic Michelle's Mad Batter is the place Mitchell locals go to for just about every occasion, and Thanksgiving is no exception. Reach out on their website for a custom dessert to get your hands on a pumpkin pie this season. In past years, they've offered a sampler option, so you could get a mix of fruit, pumpkin and nut pies. Keep an eye out for unique offerings from them as the holiday approaches! Betty's Pies Duluth Media Group file photo Nostalgia is the name of the game at Betty's Pies in Two Harbors. The pumpkin pie is a favorite for many across the state at Thanksgiving. It has a smooth custard filling on a homemade crust. Order early to get yours by Thanksgiving, as they sell out fast. Pies start at $60. ADVERTISEMENT Hugo's Sometimes, finding the best pie in town is as simple as heading to the grocery store. Hugo's Family Marketplace in Grand Forks has an exceptional bakery that is reliable for all kinds of sweet treats. Stop by the bakery counter to order ahead, or take a chance and look for a classic pumpkin pie in the case when you do your Thanksgiving grocery shopping. Pies N' More Chris Flynn / The Forum About 45 miles west of Fargo, a woman in Tower City has reached legendary status for her pies. Rhonda Nelson once baked at a now-closed cafe and now sells her pies independently at Pies 'N More. Her fresh-baked pies are built on the perfect base of from-scratch crust. The pumpkin pie is classic and tastes homemade — because it is. Pies are $23 each and can be ordered via Facebook message. Dave the Pie Guy Twin Cities residents don't need to go far to find the perfect pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving. Dave the Pie Guy is accepting preorders for homemade pies for the holiday and is even open on Thanksgiving. The pumpkin pie is made from scratch, using real pumpkins to build that earthy flavor. Pies start at $40, with order forms available online. Whether you have a favorite pie shop already or are looking to sample a slice from somewhere new this year, these are bakeries you can rely on to help make your holiday a success. ADVERTISEMENT Find more of the Midwest's best bites The best way to spend a day in Rochester Whether you're a Rochester local looking for ways to spend a day off or planning a visit from afar, you'll have a fantastic time visiting these Best of the Best winners. 5d ago · By Kaity Young The Upper Midwest's top sandwich shops On National Sandwich Day, make your way to these legendary local sandwich shops for delicious bites you won't soon forget. Nov 2 · By Kaity Young Grand Forks' favorite places to watch a UND game Whether you like to watch the game with a rowdy crowd or a quieter group of fans, these bars and restaurants across Grand Forks have you covered. Oct 28 · By Kaity Young 9 fall cocktails and beers to savor this season Whether you enjoy a classic, ice-cold beer on a fall evening or like to sip a creative cocktail featuring iconic fall flavors, you'll find something to suit your palate on this list. Oct 26 · By Kaity Young Bite into autumn with these fall pastries Fall pastries are here! Find rolls, bars, donuts and cookies packed with pumpkin, caramel, pecans and cinnamon at some of the Upper Midwest's favorite bakeries. Oct 19 · By Kaity Young The best way to spend a day in Duluth Plan your day of shopping, food and fun in the Duluth area with these 2026 Best of the Best winners! Oct 16 · By Kaity Young Where to find the best apps on game day Discover where to find the best appetizers to share with friends while you root for your favorite team. Sep 21 · By Alaina Bergquist Nightlife in Duluth: The best places to eat, drink and play after dark Explore the best places to spend an evening in Duluth and Superior. Sep 14 · By Alaina Bergquist Fargo-Moorhead's favorite places to watch a Bison game Whether you like a calmer spot or want a high-energy hub for your game day fix, bars and restaurants across the Fargo-Moorhead area have you covered. Sep 9 · By Kaity Young Share Share this article Share Facebook X LinkedIn Email Print News Promotion News Promotion An article written by the newsroom that draws attention to other article(s) of interest. The Trust Project What is this? Tags Tags FOOD RESTAURANTS AND BARS MINNESOTA NORTH DAKOTA SOUTH DAKOTA THANKSGIVING FARGO ROCHESTER TWO HARBORS MINNEAPOLIS GRAND FORKS MITCHELL SPICER DICKINSON By Kaity Young Kaity Young is the content manager for Best of the Midwest. She joined the company in 2018 and is on an eternal quest for the world's best latte. Listen to this article What to Read Next 5 Upper Midwest museums to visit this winter 2d ago · By Kaity Young Can't-miss November events across the Upper Midwest Nov 4 · By Alaina Bergquist A shopper’s guide to Detroit Lakes Oct 30 · By Elizabeth Moe Spooky places to stay this fall in Minnesota Oct 23 · By Alaina Bergquist Get Local